San Francisco

No single remark characterizes better what San Francisco means for many people than a quip by Herb Caen, the city’s late chronicler par excellence: “One day if I do go to heaven ... I'll look around and say, 'It ain't bad, but it ain't San Francisco .’ ”

That simple statement aptly summarizes the affection and high regard many residents and visitors hold for the City by the Bay. These 49 square miles of hill and valley and shore have commanded the attention not only of the state in which it was for many decades the most important city, but also the imagination of a nation that considers it both a point of departure (people come here looking to reinvent and rediscover themselves) and a point of no return (with the Golden Gate Bridge having the dubious distinction of being the No. 1 place to check out of this old world and into the great beyond).

What gives San Francisco its allure? The 50 or so hills on which it spreads, affording wow-inspiring views not only from the top but also from the bottom looking up? Its mix of low-slung Victorian buildings and modern architectural marvels? The cable cars and streetcars and ferries and other reminders of a more felicitous era in public transit? The area’s quirky sea-induced weather, which can vary by hour from misty to crystal clear to breezy then blustery, with the fog playing hide-and-seek all the while? Or, in spite of that persistent fog, the fact that it still averages 260 sunny days a year, no snow in the winter, and 20 to 22 inches of precipitation annually, 90 percent of which falls between mid-October and mid-April? Perhaps it’s the curiously laid-back yet politically engaged and diverse population, almost 45 percent of whom have college degrees? The fact that 60 percent of San Franciscans are single? The food-obsessed lifestyle, with nearly 3,000 restaurants—the most per capita of any U.S. city? The liberal politics that encourages tolerance of many ways of life? Or, on a more practical note, is it the resilient economy, with its banking and finance industry driving Web 2.0 entrepreneurs as well as biotechnology and biomedical research, bumping the median household income to more than $70,000 a year? Or is the attraction as simple as the beauty of the city’s setting, surrounded by bay and ocean on three sides, with glorious countryside, open space, and mountains beckoning a few miles away?

The People
However you explain its pull, San Francisco indeed induces many to come, most of them to visit (15 million a year, according to the city's Convention and Visitors Bureau) and a smaller number to stay and live here—population in the last decade has hovered near 800,000, with the U.S. Census Bureau estimating a 2009 total of about 815,000, including about 100,000 who moved to the city in the last five years.

Though San Francisco is a densely populated place, it is in fact not even in the top 10 nationwide, at No. 23 among specific areas (some located within municipal boundaries, like Manhattan) with high-density population--but still more packed with people per square mile than Chicago, Boston, and Philadelphia, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. It is the 14th most populous city in the United States, however, and the second most densely populated of U.S. cities among those with more than 200,000 residents ( New York City is first). The large number of foreign-born immigrants (about 36 percent of the total, according to the Census Bureau) gives the city its characteristic diversity; it is often referred to as a “minority-majority” city, with non-Hispanic whites making up less than half of the population. (Latinos—white or of any race—amount to 14 percent of the total.) Asians of any nationality comprise about 31 percent of the population, those born in China or of Chinese descent being the largest single ethnic group in San Francisco, at about 20 percent. But the city’s African-American population has declined for the last 40 years, from 13 percent in 1970 to 7 percent today.

The city contains a lower-than-average number of married people (40 percent) with the lowest percentage of children under 18 of any metropolis in the United States (about 15 percent). San Francisco also counts 15 percent of its total population as gays and lesbians, according to figures from a survey conducted by the UCLA School of Law. That figure—the highest percentage in the nation—helps explain the highest per-capita distribution of same-sex households here as well as the gay-friendly civic government and businesses.

The Politics
Numerous factors in San Francisco’s past—its anything-goes history in the Gold Rush and Barbary Coast days in the 1850s and ’60s; the influx of immigrants in the early- and mid-20th century; the strong unions that organized workers in the Depression and World War II; the cultural foment of the Beat Generation in the 1950s and the Summer of Love in 1967; the gay-rights movement of the 1970s; and the environmental and “green” revolutions of the 1980s and 1990s—have resulted in an overall liberal political climate in city governance and a general tolerance exhibited by most of the populace.

San Francisco is constituted as a consolidated city and county. The mayor serves as the county executive and heads other citywide elected and appointed officials, and the 11-member Board of Supervisors acts as both a county delegation as well as the city council. Under the city charter, these two branches are equal, with the mayor in charge of the day-to-day operations of the civic government, and the supervisors, led by a president, responsible for passing laws and budgets. The city is divided into 11 geographic districts, each of which is represented by one member of the board, who in turn reflects the demographics of his or her constituency, with more conservative districts traditionally located in the city’s western and southwestern areas.

The city has been solidly Democratic for the last half-century, with no Republican presidential candidate winning over the city’s electorate since Dwight Eisenhower in the 1950s. At present, most of the city is represented in Congress by Rep. Nancy Pelosi, the Speaker of the House of Representatives and the first woman to fill the post. This is not to suggest that San Francisco moves in liberal lockstep: the Byzantine nature of politics here, which tends to pit one interest group against another, frequently creates conflicts over development (particularly between downtown corporations and the neighborhoods) and the apportionment of city services (police and fire protection, public transit routes, and health care).

Despite the liberal veneer, many newcomers to the city marvel at apparent contradictions in freedoms. For instance, while some patently illegal activity (smoking marijuana for non-medical purposes) is mostly ignored by the authorities as well as the citizenry, other perfectly legal activity (smoking tobacco) is severely restricted (it’s prohibited indoors in public places, in parks, and in taxis) and frowned upon by the populace. Others, newbies and oldsters alike, also bristle at the enforced recycling policies of the city, where residents are required to sort from their trash such recoverable, renewable resources as paper, glass, aluminum, and plastic, and to place compostable items such as kitchen scraps, soiled paper, and garden waste in green containers. Though detested by some and embraced wholeheartedly by others, the policy has resulted in San Francisco leading the nation with the most waste recycled of any U.S. municipality—nearly 67 percent (according to SustainLane.com).

The embrace of diversity and tolerance is also contradicted by a strong not-in-my-backyard streak among many neighborhood groups, who shun further intrusion into their protected space by opposing most development (including, at times, affordable housing) on the grounds that it will interfere with their area’s historic significance or quality of life. The Board of Supervisors has historically issued strong growth-control laws as well, empowering the Planning Department to limit, curtail, and even refuse developments it considers inharmonious with the city’s planning code.

The Neighborhoods
It is often said that San Francisco is less a big city and more a collection of small ones, and surely its neighborhoods bear that out. They are among the most distinct in any urban area of the United States, reflecting not only the current residents but, thanks to the city’s active historic preservation groups, its past inhabitants and their buildings and cultural landmarks as well.

Many neighborhoods are formed by man-made boundaries—busy streets, a park, a famous monument. Others are delimited by natural boundaries—the crest of a hill or the hill itself, the slope of one of these hills versus its counterpart on the other side, even waterways like lakes and brackish creeks that empty into the bay. In still others, the definition of one place versus another is forever in flux: consider the inability of anyone to say exactly where Hayes Valley ends and the Lower Haight begins.

Fluid boundaries notwithstanding, San Francisco is a mosaic of different neighborhoods, each exhibiting its own flavor and character. Take the Mission District, an area that was settled in the late 19th century by European immigrants, the different groups bringing their commercial and social influences to the pockets where they clustered (trades, restaurants, churches, and clubs). Today, however, it has a decidedly Latino atmosphere, with Mission and Valencia streets crowded with stores and businesses catering to a Spanish-speaking clientele from Mexico as well as Central and South America. Likewise Chinatown: in a dark moment of the city’s 19th-century past, the Chinese Exclusion Act effectively sequestered Chinese residents on Grant Avenue and severely limited their freedoms to move outside the area and conduct business. Today, however, the infamous law receding into the past, the neighborhood has grown beyond the Grant Avenue tourist corridor to include large swaths abutting Nob Hill, North Beach, and Telegraph Hill, its vibrant shops, restaurants, and businesses catering to a new wave of Chinese immigrants.

Although ethnicity defines these two enclaves, most San Francisco neighborhoods are less influenced by race and culture and more by lifestyle. The Castro, for instance, is known worldwide as a gay mecca, while nearby Haight-Ashbury, famous for its 1960s hippie invasion, still attracts a considerable contingent of young people adhering to a similar sex-drugs-rock-’n’-roll philosophy. Noe Valley has its own counterculture family values, with high-tech millionaires pushing baby strollers next to designers, writers, and trades people of all types. And the Marina District pulls in both the young and well-heeled along with moneyed bankers and well-off retirees. From the well-to-do of Pacific Heights and Russian Hill to the down-to-earth of Bernal Heights and Bayview-Hunters Point, San Francisco still manages to accommodate all levels of the socio-economic stratum.

Newer areas like Mission Bay and older ones that have seen new life like South of Market (or SoMa, in real-estate parlance) are seen as more open to development and new industry. Hence, Mission Bay ’s satellite campus of UCSF and its many biotech firms, along with SoMa’s openness to multi-unit/multi-use housing developments and live/work lofts.

There is considerable cross-pollination among the neighborhoods as well, allowing for transitions and shared traditions (the annual gay parade, for instance, takes place downtown, on Market Street and in Civic Center, far from the Castro, and the yearly Bay to Breakers run cuts through numerous districts). Ethnic eateries dot most neighborhoods, and not always in line with the population: hence, you’ll find a Korean barbecue in Noe Valley, Thai food in the Mission, Chinese in North Beach, and Italian in the Sunset. Needless to say, churches and temples draw worshipers from various neighborhoods as well: Grace Cathedral on Nob Hill brings residents from all over the city, as does Congregation Emanu-El in the Inner Richmond.

Cultural Life
With such an educated population and a concentration of wealthy benefactors, it follows that San Francisco has developed a rich and varied arts and culture scene. Topping the list are its world-class symphony, opera, and ballet companies. Led by music director and principal conductor Michael Tilson Thomas (often said to be the greatest musical educator since Leonard Bernstein), the San Francisco Symphony draws high-caliber musicians, guest artists, and conductors from throughout the world, and its concerts are often sold out. San Francisco Opera also adds international luster to the performing arts, wooing marquee sopranos and tenors for extended runs in its fall and summer seasons. San Francisco Ballet, under Artistic Director and Principal Choreographer Helgi Tomasson, has assembled a multinational cast of principals and soloists, as well as corps dancers (many from the company’s school), who perform classical and modern works by a roster of leading choreographers.

Although live theater here suffers because high real-estate prices make venue rentals almost prohibitive, there are still important regional companies based in San Francisco, including the American Conservatory Theater (famous for turning out actors like Annette Bening, Denzel Washington, and Winona Ryder while premiering many new works on the West Coast) and the Magic Theater, which devotes itself to new works by emerging and established playwrights, including Sam Shepard. San Francisco also has its own brand of improv, in which full-evening works and even musicals are performed extemporaneously at various small theaters in town.

Five world-class museums each offer their particular collections—SFMOMA, with its works by 20th-century artists housed in the intriguing Mario Botta-designed “zebra dome” edifice in Yerba Buena and soon to include the collection of GAP Co-Founder Donald Fisher; the deYoung in Golden Gate Park, with its eclectic collection of American, African, and Pacific Island works; the California Palace of the Legion of Honor in Lincoln Park, which houses fine sculpture and pottery from European antiquity through the 19th century; the Asian Art Museum, designed by Gae Aulenti (famous for her work with the Musée d’Orsay in Paris) to fill the old main library building with an impressive cross-section of works from across Asia over the last 6,000 years; and the California Academy of Sciences, also located in Golden Gate Park, with its new building housing a tropical rainforest as well as an aquarium and planetarium.

There are also numerous community-centered museums and galleries, including the Mexican Museum and Contemporary Jewish Museum opposite Yerba Buena Gardens and exhibit spaces in the neighborhoods themselves (Galería de la Raza in the Mission, the Fine Museum in the Temple Emanu-El ). The Exploratorium, next to the Palace of Fine Arts in the Marina District, is an interactive science with many programs geared to schoolchildren.

The city’s vibrant pop- and rock-music scene is centered in a number of clubs in South of Market (Slim’s, Brainwash, Hotel Utah, Annie’s Social Club, DNA Lounge, 330 Ritch Street) and in the Mission District (Elbo Room, El Rio, Amnesia, Make-Out Room) with a few venues in the Fillmore (Boom Boom Room, the Fillmore) and on or around Polk Street (Red Devil Lounge, Hemlock Tavern, Great American Music Hall, Edinburgh Castle). Though the musical genres have come a long way since the Grateful Dead and Jefferson Airplane (with DJs rising in popularity, blending everything from disco and house to trance and techno), today’s “San Francisco Sound” is still very much live and in person.

Restaurants and Food
Known as a “foodie” town, San Francisco harbors hundreds of restaurants, many of them ethnic and a number of them ground-breakers in modern culinary trends, from Aziza (classic Moroccan with Mediterranean overtones) to Zuni (nouveau California, with an emphasis on fresh fish and grilled dishes). Because of the number of recent immigrants who now call San Francisco home, the city enjoys a wide variety of culinary styles, including Chinese (dim sum to Peking duck), Indian (tandoori to curries), Thai, Korean, Japanese, Mexican (especially taquerias), South American (from Peruvian to Brazilian), and an array of French and Italian restaurants, many of the latter in the Financial District or concentrated around North Beach, the traditional center of the city’s first Italian immigrants.

As with the eateries they flock to, San Franciscans also take pleasure in the number of groceries and fresh food outlets they can frequent, along with the array of unusual ingredients home chefs can choose from. With its weekly farmer’s markets at Ferry Plaza, United Nations Plaza, and Alemany Boulevard, many residents have taken to their kitchens with a passion, seeking out the best meats and produce along with cheeses, bread, and wines—obliged by small specialty food shops as well as bigger outlets like Real Food, Whole Foods, and Trader Joe’s. It all combines to create a food-oriented culture that is centered on dinner parties or going out to try the latest addition to eateries in the neighborhood, then recreating the experience at home.

Schools
Though San Francisco is not renowned for model public schools (it has struggled in the last decades with budget cuts and a shifting population of students, many of them underprivileged and speaking English as a second language), there are a number of notable exceptions, including Lowell High School (with its national reputation as a magnet for the college-bound) as well as exemplary elementary schools such as Claire Lilienthal, Alice Fong Yu, and Rooftop Academy. GreatSchools gives the city’s public schools overall a 6 out of 10 rating.

And although public schools leave something to be desired, the city is perhaps better represented by its private elementary and high schools, especially those centered on or near Pacific Heights: Town School and Stuart Hall (both for boys); Drew (coed); Sacred Heart (coed, Catholic)—the list goes on. As with most private schools in an environment that is increasingly deprived of government funding, the cost of a primary education can equal or top that of what colleges and universities charge (i.e., $30,000 a year).

Transit and Parking
San Francisco has always been a city that needed to provide its citizens a means to scale the steep hills, and that legacy is evident today in the network of streetcars, buses, and subways that connect the various areas with each other. Though MUNI buses, the most common feature of the city-run public transit system, are often criticized for flouting their schedules and leaving many riders guessing when the next one might arrive, they are fairly consistent and get begrudgingly good marks from the ridership (as a recent MUNI-sponsored survey showed). The subway, which runs primarily along Market Street underground—mimicking BART, the regional train commuter system—is a vital key to attracting the large percentage of city residents who commute to work via public transportation. The historic cable cars (which run via a cable under the street) and streetcars (which run on tracks on the surface, powered by overhead electric lines) round out the transit options within the city proper.

BART, Golden Gate Transit (buses and ferries to Marin and Sonoma counties), and SamTrans (buses to San Mateo County) serve the city's travelers as well as commuters from around the Bay Area. San Francisco International Airport, located in San Mateo County, is the largest of the Bay Area airports, and can be accessed by BART as well as a number of local bus routes.

Because of the high population density and the number of residents who, despite public transportation options, use their cars to get around, parking in San Francisco can be difficult to nightmarish; fines for double-parking, parking in a bus zone, and overtime parking are steep, and can also result in expensive towing (nearly $300 alone, excluding the fine). Because of the difficulties of on-street parking for residents, the San Francisco Department of Parking and Traffic issues residential permits for $96 a year, enabling neighborhood residents to park their vehicles in time-limited zones without fear of being ticketed.

Crime
Although San Francisco has improved its record on violent crime in the last few years (assaults and sexual attacks are down, near or lower than the national average), homicides remain almost 50 percent higher than the national average, according to FBI crime reports. San Francisco has also seen a considerable uptick in the last few years of vehicle thefts, car break-ins, and burglaries and robberies. As can be expected, the number and frequency of crimes committed varies with the neighborhood and the demographics of its population; poorer areas tend to have a higher incidence of criminal activity.

Real estate:
San Francisco has weathered the recent economic downturn with its real estate market fairly intact. Though price depends to a great degree on the area in which a home is located, median sales prices are up by more than 7 percent since 2009, when the latest recession caused many listings to drop by as much as 20 percent, according to Trulia.com. The median home price in San Francisco, according to the online real-estate service, is still high, at $675,000, for an average two-bedroom, two-bathroom dwelling (both condo and single-family).

The rental market, after a small and short-lived dip, is also showing signs of resuming its recent robust pricing: according to Trulia, the average rent for a studio in San Francisco is $1,300 a month, with one- and two-bedrooms going for upward of $1,800. Again, location determines the bottom line, with units in high-density (and high-crime) areas going for less than more desirable, quiet neighborhoods.

Downsides
Not everything is bliss in San Francisco, of course. Trash is increasingly a problem as the city’s population expands and more residents crowd its streets and public spaces. The city’s Department of Public Works has attempted to alleviate the filth with highly efficient street sweepers and effective trash removal, but much of the problem is owing to increased pedestrian traffic and a commercial culture reliant on easily discarded packaging. The cost of living here is also high, as much as twice the national average, according to Sperling’s Best Places. But it’s a price many seem willing to pay, especially given the returns in higher wages and amenities like good public transit and easy access to recreation. And although everyone complains about the fog, it is true that some areas have it worse than others (travel east on Geary Boulevard from Ocean Beach to Union Square and you’ll get a crash course in the city’s fog zones). Still, for all of its drawbacks, the fog keeps the cool gray city of love air conditioned most days in the summer.

Many residents, native and newcomer alike, engage in the age-old pastime of complaining about how fast things change in this city, how quickly it moves from ideal to less-than-idyllic. That seems to be part of life here as well. As that former Chronicle scribe, Herb Caen, also wrote: “San Francisco isn't what it used to be, and it never was.”